Hartville
4.7

out of 5

Hartville Pet Insurance for Dog & Cat

Updated: May 29, 2024

Hartville Pet Insurance offers accident and illness coverage for dogs and cats. It is underwritten by Independence American Insurance Company and offers a variety of plans to choose from, with different levels of coverage and deductibles. Plans start at just $15 per month.

Hartville Pet Insurance Details

    • Why Our Users Picked It:

      Our users appreciate that Hartville offers flexible coverage options as far as policy limits, deductibles and reimbursement rates. This puts them in the driver’s seat and allows them to choose a policy they can comfortably afford.

      Pros & Cons:

      • Flexible coverage options
      • Annual coverage limits range from $2,500 to unlimited (great option for senior pets)
      • Optional wellness plan
      • Doesn’t cover alternative care
      • Potential premium increases
      • Longer times to reimbursements

      Plan Limits

      • Per Condition Limit Unlimited
      • Lifetime Limit Unlimited
      • Deductible Type Annual
      • Direct Pay

      What is Covered?

      • Accident and Injury Covered up to the selected annual limit for accident and injury only ($2,500-Unlimited)
      • Hospitalization Covered up to the selected annual limit for accidents, injuries and illnesses ($2,500-Unlimited)
      • Rehabilitation Covered up to the selected annual limit for accident and injury only ($2,500-Unlimited)
      • Continual Care Covered up to the selected annual limit for accident and injury only ($2,500-Unlimited)
      • Emergency Visits Covered up to the selected annual limit for both accidents and illnesses ($2,500-Unlimited)
      • Surgery Covered up to the selected annual limit for accident and injury only ($2,500-Unlimited)
      • Dental Trauma Covered up to the selected annual limit for accident and injury only ($2,500-Unlimited)
      • Foreign Object Ingestion Covered up to the selected annual limit for accident and injury only ($2,500-Unlimited)
      • Congenital or Hereditary Conditions
      • Cancer Treatments Covered with a Complete Coverage plan, up to the selected annual limit ($2,500-Unlimited)
      • Dietary Supplements Prescription food & supplements are covered if they are prescribed to treat an eligible accident or illness. Prescription food & supplements are not covered if they are used for weight management or general health maintenance.
      • End of Life: Burial and Cremation Covered up to the selected annual limit for accident and injury only ($2,500-Unlimited)
      • Illness Covered with a Complete Coverage plan, up to the selected annual limit ($2,500-Unlimited)
      • Specialists Covered up to the selected annual limit for accident and injury only ($2,500-Unlimited)
      • Prosthetics
      • End of Life: Euthanasia Covered up to the selected annual limit for accident and injury only ($2,500-Unlimited)
      • Prescription Drugs Covered up to the selected annual limit for accident and injury only ($2,500-Unlimited)
      • Outpatient Care Covered up to the selected annual limit for accident and injury only ($2,500-Unlimited)
      • Bilateral Conditions If any ligament and knee condition occurred prior to the first effective date of the applicable coverage or during a waiting period they will no longer be covered.
      • Travel Coverage If a pet is traveling within the U.S., it's territores or Canada it is covered. We do not pay for traveling expenses (i.e. if the veterinarian has to come to the pet owner's home)
      • Vet Exam Fees Covered up to the selected annual limit for both accidents and illnesses ($2,500-Unlimited)
      • Medical Imaging Covered up to the selected annual limit for accident and injury only ($2,500-Unlimited)
      • Organ Transplants
      • Wellness Cover Optional Preventive Care add-ons provides a benefit schedule with set reimbursement amounts for select services
      • Lab Tests "Diagnostic Testing (Lab Tests)": Covered up to the selected annual limit for both accidents and illnesses
      • Behavioral Treatments Covered up to the selected annual limit for accident and injury only ($2,500-Unlimited)

      Plan Summary

      Hartville Pet Insurance, provided by Crum & Forster Pet Insurance Group through its licensed agency, C&F Insurance Agency, Inc., is committed to improving animal care across the U.S. by making veterinary care more affordable for pet parents. Their Complete Coverage(SM) plan covers accidents, injuries, illnesses and more, and features simplified reimbursement based on percentage of invoice. Preventive Care is available at an additional cost.

    Most popular dog breeds insured by Hartville Pet Insurance

    Here are the top 10 dog breeds covered by the Hartville Pet Insurance program so you can get an idea of the possible monthly costs.

    Breed Average Monthly Cost
    Other Mixed Breed (Medium Mix 26-50lbs) $20.35
    German Shepherd $25.15
    Golden Retriever $29.64
    Labrador Retriever $29.64
    Yorkshire Terrier $17.12
    Scottish Terrier $24.19
    Poodle - Toy $20.35
    Poodle - Miniature $17.12
    Miniature Yorkshire Terrier $20.35
    Miniature Pinscher $20.35
    Pricing based on 2 yr old pet in 44718 zip code, with $5,000 Annual Limit, $500 Deductible and 70% Reimbursement. Cost varies based on user selected coverage.

    Most popular cat breeds insured by Hartville Pet Insurance

    Here are the top 10 cat breeds covered by the Hartville Pet Insurance program so you can get an idea of the possible monthly costs.

    Breed Average Monthly Cost
    Domestic Short Hair $11.97
    Siamese $11.97
    Mixed Cat $11.97
    Turkish Angora $11.97
    Ragdoll $11.97
    Domestic Mediumhair $11.97
    Domestic Longhair $11.97
    Cameo Longhair $16.51
    Bombay $10.72
    Pricing based on 2 yr old pet in 44718 zip code, with $5,000 Annual Limit, $500 Deductible and 70% Reimbursement. Cost varies based on user selected coverage.
    Get a Quote & Compare

    Compare With Other Top Pet Insurance Providers 2024

    • Users appreciate the efficiency of claims processing and prompt reimbursement. They also love the great customer service Embrace offers.
    • Many users have said how much they appreciate the simplicity and user-friendly nature of the Healthy Paws app and website for submitting claims. Users also praise the quick turnaround time for claim review and reimbursement, with some receiving payments within 48 hours.
    • Many of our users stated they found Trupanion’s customer service to be exceptional. Responses are prompt and helpful. In addition, many find the claims process to be simple, efficient and user-friendly.
    • Users appreciate that Fetch offers up to 90% reimbursement rates. Some have also expressed the ease of submitting claims, with some saying they submitted claims in the vet’s office from their phone within minutes.
    • Quite a few users have mentioned that Lemonade offers some of the most affordable policies in the market. Many also appreciate that coverage is extensive and covers a wide range of medical conditions and procedures.
    • Users appreciate the effortless claim process and timely refunds in as little as 24-48 hours. Comprehensive coverage with up to 90% of bills covered has also been highlighted by many.
    • Our users have raved about how easy it is to submit claims through Prudent Pet. Some have also left great reviews highlighting Prudent Pet’s direct deposit of reimbursement payments. Great customer service seems to be another main theme with this provider.
    • Many users have praised Spot for their quick and hassle-free claim process. They also mention how quickly they are reimbursed in most cases and that customer service is both kind and helpful.
    • Users love the great customer service offered by Many Pets and the fact that they offer competitive pricing. Many Pets will also reduce the accident and illness waiting period to 24 hours if you are switching from another insurance provider.
    • Reviewers highlighted how wonderful customer service is. Not just responsive and knowledgeable but also really compassionate during times of stress and worry. One person even mentioned how the company sent flowers after her pet had to be euthanized.
    • Users appreciate that the ASPCA Pet Health Insurance program offers up to 90% reimbursement of covered conditions for services relating to emergency visits, chronic conditions, alternative therapies and even things you may not think about like prescription medications. For an additional price per month, one of two optional Preventive Care plans can be selected to reimburse on things that help keep your pet healthy. Many users have also highlighted the positive experience of working with the helpful and responsive customer services representatives.
    • Users have raved about the awesome customer service this provider offers. Some have also highlighted quick turnaround time for payments once a claim has been submitted.
    • Some reviewers have praised AKC for offering an easy claims submission process. Others have said how much they appreciate the great customer service and that payments are generally made within days of making a claim.
    • Users rave about how easy it is to submit a claim and receive updates on it. Many have also said how much they appreciate how fast reimbursements are. The company has also been highly praised for its transparent coverage policies and clear communication.
    • Reviewers appreciate that Figo offers Wellness coverage for preventative care. Many also mentioned the claims process was hassle-free.
    • Our users raved about MetLife’s exceptional customer service and the fact the company offers comprehensive coverage that supports both preventative and emergency care. And users also appreciate MetLife’s competitive pricing.

    Select up to 3 providers to compare

    Hartville Pet Insurance FAQ?

    • Does Hartville drop coverage when a pet gets older?

      Not at all. No matter how old your fur baby gets, Hartville pet insurance will never be canceled or downgraded. However, you may see an increase in your premium as they get older.

    • Does Hartville limit the number of claims I can submit?

      Not at all. Though according to their website, it does help if you submit your claim within 270 days of your pet’s vet visit.

    • How does Hartville pet insurance pay reimbursements?

      Hartville leaves that up to you. You can have a check sent to you via snail mail, or sign up for direct deposits.

    • How long does it take for Hartville pet insurance to process claims?

      On their website, Hartville says they typically process claims in 30 days or less. That is quite a bit longer than many pet insurance companies who reimburse customers within 2-7 days.

    • Does Hartville limit where I can use my pet insurance?

      No. You can use Hartville pet insurance at any licensed veterinary clinic in the U.S. or Canada, including emergency clinics and specialists.

    Get a quote today

    Leave a review